Dined on April 30, 2016

We have been dining at Victor’s for a number of years and have never been disappointed. It’s difficult to imagine but the food and service keep getting better and better. The salmon was amazing. It had a coffee/chocolate sauce lightly drizzled over top and the salmon itself melted in your mouth. The waiter was also extremely good. He knew the specials without reading them and even though we had some special food orders, everything came out perfect, hot and on time. I highly recommend Victor’s for the food, service and atmosphere.”


Wonderful wait staff

Dined on April 27, 2016

The waiter was so personable and attentive! He had such a wonderful smile and was so accomodating! Food was so good and the presentation was great!


Excellent server. Seasonal menu so every …

Dined on April 23, 2016

“Excellent server. Seasonal menu so everything is fresh and amazing. I had a tough time picking something because all of it sounded delicious. Chef stopped by the table at the end to see how everything was. Overall 10/10”


Everything was great

Dined on April 16, 2016

“We really enjoyed our visit to Victors. The beet salad was great and our guests enjoyed the kale salad as well. We ordered the salmon, special lobster ravioli, swordfish special and the shrimp papardelle. Our wine was late getting to the table and our dinner was almost over but dessert was good. We had the creme brulle, cheese cake and ice cream. We will be back again. The dining room is nicely decorated, rather small and intimate.”


Pleased with our choice

Dined on April 5, 2016

My husband and I chose Victor’s to celebrate our anniversary on 4/5/16. We both enjoy the fine dining scene, and make it a point to visit as many restaurants as we can. This was our first time dining here, and we thoroughly enjoyed it. I like that the atmosphere is unique, in that it was an old church at one point in history. The ambience was romantic, which was perfect considering the occasion we were enjoying. Our waitress allowed us to taste a wine, to be sure we were happy with our choice. She was also very knowledgeable about the menu, and the current specials they were offering. We enjoyed every aspect of the menu, from the appetizer to dessert. Everything was very savory & flavorful. Thank you for making our anniversary special with wonderful food & spirits!”


Great little place

Dined on March 22, 2016

“Delicious cheese board app and meals, attentive and friendly staff. Absolutely need to make reservations, well worth it. We’ll be back!”



Dined on March 17, 2016

“I went to Victors with my gf for her birthday. When we first walked in and saw the bar we got scared, but they have a wall seperating it from the rest of the restaurant and it was nice quiet and romantic. Food was excellent, ambiance was very pleasant, and our waiter was fantastic. What more could you ask from a restaurant?!”



Dined on March 8, 2016

“One of the top restaurants in York. Off the beaten path and well worth seeking out. Chef George does northern creative Italian like no other in the region. A dozen or more excellent wines by the glass and more by the bottle. Victors is our all around favorite and first choice.”



Dined on January 8, 2016

“Victor’s continues to be a favorite in our family, and this was no exception. 3 (of the 4) of us ordered the unique seasonal dishes. My dish was the duck breast – the menu gives an accurate description so I won’t repeat. What I will say is that I rarely find duck on menus in the US and usually go with when I find…this meal was executed perfectly! Medium rare, tender, and very flavorful which worked well with the side items. My daughter loved the salmon dish and my wife loved the shrimp & scallop seasonal dish. The cheese/meat tray appetizer is a unique interpretation with different selections. Only disappointment from the night – my wine selection (by the glass) ran out after first glass. It was excellent, and had to move to a second choice later in the meal.”

trip advisor

“Great place”

Reviewed 2 weeks ago via mobile

“We started in the lounge where Jody was a great bartender funny fast and a great drinks we then enjoyed a fabulous meal and the atmosphere in the old church building is unique it is higher priced than a chain type restaurant but the food is definitely different as well”

Exceptional Food and Service”

Reviewed 2 weeks ago via mobile

“If you need a nice place for a quiet business luncheon in a relaxed atmosphere this is the perfect restaurant out of the center of the city but close to the interstate very nice furnishings and plenty of parking. Plenty of parking. Close to the interstate and very family-friendly

Windy today small table for a quiet business luncheon and they provided us exactly what we needed very attentive staff very exceptional authentic Italian cuisine and they showed us there dinner menu which I plan to take advantage of in the near future with my wife”

Visited March 2016


“Excellent experience”

Reviewed March 31, 2016

“We founded the food to be delicious, well prepared, and served very nicely. The staff was particularly friendly, and the service was attentive without being overly done. The warm bread with olive oil dip was a very nice touch. I had the sausage and shrimp, which was delightfully flavorful. My wife had the egg plant Parmesan, which was extrodinary. The portions size was just right, not too much, and not too little. This restaurant is a definite gem.”

  • Visited March 2016


“Return to Victor’s After 10 Years”

Reviewed February 28, 2016

“We had not been to Victor’s in 10 years. A chef’s special was not so special back then and we never returned until last night. We have a tendency to cross restaurants off the list when we have a bad meal.

Some friends of ours selected the restaurant and drove, so we had no choice but to go. Much to our surprise, the service was impeccable and the food even better. I had the Beet Salad and Chicken Parmesan, which was excellent. My wife had the shrimp wrapped in prosciutto and the Winter Gnocchi. Our friends had the Chef’s special with pork tenderloin, which looked great and were confirmed as outstanding dishes.

We had the Lava Cake for dessert with coffee.

Truly as fantastic dining experience, with excellent customer service.

We will be back.”

  • Visited February 2016


“Delicious, authentic Italian cuisine”

Reviewed February 17, 2016

“I had the scallop risotto and it was divine! It came in a small plate portion, which was perfect since it was so very rich. I also enjoy the quaint atmosphere. It can get a little noisy, due to the close quarters and high church ceilings, but it is cozy none the less.”

  • Visited February 2016


“Wonderful food”

Reviewed February 17, 2016

“The restaurant in in a former church so that makes it a unique setting. It has outdoor seating in the warmer months. The food is wonderful. The menu changes so you might not always be able to get the same meal but there will be something equally delicious to have. It’s a bit pricey for frequent dining but the perfect place for special occasions.”

  • Visited October 2015